Abdorrahman Boroumand Center

for Human Rights in Iran

https://www.iranrights.org
Omid, a memorial in defense of human rights in Iran
One Person’s Story

Isa Pirvali

About

Nationality: Iran
Religion: Presumed Muslim
Civil Status: Unknown

Case

Date of Killing: August 27, 1979
Location of Killing: Sanandaj Airport, Sanandaj, Kordestan Province, Iran
Mode of Killing: Shooting
Charges: Murder

About this Case

Information about the execution of Mr. Isa Pirvali has been gathered by the Boroumand Foundation from the report “The Demise of Sadeq Khalkhali” by Mansur Boluri (Iranian Political Bulletin, 30 November 2003), and the book Ayam-e Enzava (Times of Solitude) by Ayatollah Khalkhali. Additional information has been drawn from the book Sahifeh-ye Emam by Ayatollah Khomeini, volume 9, the report Murder at Mykonos published by the Iran Human Rights Documentation Center, as well as the article “A Chilling Photograph’s Hidden History” by Joshua Prager, published in The Wall Street Journal on December 02, 2006. This article tells the story of the photograph of this execution by Mr. Jahangir Razmi. According to this article, Mr. Pirvali was a sandwich-maker and did not belong to any political group.

Mr. Pirvali’s execution was part of a wave of executions that took place in order to combat the “anti-Revolutionary” elements in Kurdistan. Following the negotiations between the Democratic Party of Iranian Kurdistan (PDKI) and the interim prime minister, several clashes occurred, at times armed, between the Revolutionary Guards and the peshmerga (the militia of the PDKI) particularly in the cities of Sanandaj (Kordestan province) and Paveh (Kermanshah province). These intensifying conflicts between the new central Shiite government of Iran and the mainly Sunni Kurdistan region concerned the role of minorities in the drafting of the constitution, specification of Shiite as the official state religion, and particularly the autonomy of the region.

Subsequent to conflicts that resulted in some casualties, on August 18, 1979, Ayatollah Khomeini issued an order to the military and the armed forces to “move to Paveh and end the fighting…” In the same order, he encouraged them to use force and threatened that: “if they do not move toward Paveh within 24 hours with missiles and tanks and all necessary arsenals, I will hold them accountable. And in case of any infringement of this order, I will treat them in a Revolutionary manner” (Sahifeh-ye Emam, p. 285). On August 19, Ayatollah Khomeini called the PDKI the “party of Satan” and declared it “unofficial and illegal” noting that some of these “anti-Islamic” individuals had boycotted the referendum of April 1, when people went to polls to vote for or against the Islamic regime (ibid p. 311).

In accordance with Khomeini’s order, Ayatollah Sadeq Khalkhali traveled the western region of Iran and told a reporter from the Ettela’at newspaper: “I will visit all areas of Kurdistan… and will bring to justice anybody who was involved in these bloody plots” (Times of Solitude p. 96). According to Mr. Boluri, Ayatollah Khalkhali condemned at least 58 Kurds to death in the span of 10 days. Mass executions and conflicts continued for many months in that region.

The photograph of this execution was published in the Ettela’at (August 28, 1979). However, the newspaper did not reportedly publish the picture in the version sent to Kordestan province (Mr. Prager’s article). This photograph was also sent to and published by international press, such as The News York Times, The Washington Post, and The Daily Telegraph of London. The same day as the publication of Ettela’at, the religious judge claimed that it was not an authentic picture. On September 9, the Islamic Revolutionary Council, in a communiqué published in Enqelab-e Eslami newspaper, referred to this picture and stated: “If this occurs again, serious decisions will be made.”

Arrest and detention

The circumstances of Mr. Pirvali’s arrest and detention are not known.

Trial

According to Mr. Prager, “10 handcuffed men filled a wooden bench before the judge, a black-bearded Shiite cleric named Sadegh Khalkhali. An injured 11th prisoner lay on a stretcher beside the door. The judge removed his turban… removed his shoes. He put his feet on a chair. Scanning the prisoners through thick eyeglasses, he asked their names. Officers of the court told of the defendants’ alleged crimes.” The trial lasted for about half an hour.

Charges

Ettela’at reported the charges against Mr. Pirvali as murder of a baker and his son in Sanandaj in April of 1979 (Aug. 28, 1979).

The validity of the criminal charges brought against this defendant cannot be ascertained in the absence of the basic guarantees of a fair trial.

Evidence of guilt

According to Mr. Prager, quoting the journalist of the news story, “[n]o evidence was presented… It was pure speculation.” According to the same source, Mr. Pirvali possessed a handgun. It appears that the gun was used as evidence to prove the “murder” charge.

Defense

The defendants “denied the accusations” of “of trafficking arms, inciting riots and murder” (Mr. Prager’s article).

Judgment

The religious judge called Mr. Isa Pirvali and 10 other individuals as “corrupt on earth” and condemned them to death. At 4:30 p.m. on August 27, 1979, the defendants were taken in front of a firing squad at Sanandaj airport. Mr. Pirvali “was scared […and] wouldn’t stand… The soldiers instructed a fellow prisoner to hold him” (Mr. Prager’s article). After the shootings of the firing squad, one of the bodyguards of the judge shot each body once to ensure death.

Correct/ Complete This Entry